Reviewed by Margaret Donsbach
The Observations takes its title from a character's amateur research project of the same name. In nineteenth-century Scotland, Bessy, a young woman down on her luck and looking for whatever employment she can find, stumbles onto an estate that has seen better days. To her pleased astonishment, when she shows she can read and write, something unusual in maidservants, she is hired on the spot. Given a notebook and asked to record her daily activities and thoughts, she obliges with a bare and not always truthful minimum. Arabella, her mistress, is decidedly eccentric, overly kind some days, almost cruel others. As Bessy learns, bit by bit, about past events on the estate, she wonders and worries about the fate of the maidservant she has replaced.
Bessy's tart, sometimes bawdy narration, naive and insightful at once, is witty enough to keep readers poised between laughter and unease. The story is captivatingly original, making its twists and turns all the more unexpected. If Bessy has her flaws, she keeps a tenacious hold on the reader's sympathy. And if Arabella's carelessness with Bessy's feelings make her profoundly unsympathetic for a time, when Bessy and the reader come to know her better, she wins some forgiveness.
This is an unlikely tale, but The Observations is based on a sound understanding of nineteenth-century preoccupations. Arabella's misguided project echoes the spirit of amateur research that animated men of her time, though she fails to win the respect a man might have. Bessy and Arabella may be miles apart in social class, but both their lives are distorted by the narrowness of their culture's views about women. In the end, both prove resilient in surprising ways. (2006, 405 pages)More about The Observations at Powell's Books, Amazon.com or The Book Depository
Back to Novels of Nineteenth-Century Europe
Back to Directory of Book Reviews